Born in Russia in 1917, he dedicated
his life’s work to the people of that country. But life is full of
paradoxes. After becoming the most respected and famous scientist in
his specialty in Russia as the creator and leader of the new clinical
discipline and chief of Russian National Center of Vertebroneurology,
Popelyanskiy witnessed a collapse of the country’s economy, medical
services and research funding. He immigrated to the United States in
2000, with the intention of reporting the content of his fundamental
work and making it a part of American medicine. He wished to report
the content of his fundamental work, and to publish it in the United
States. The last 2 years of his life he was working harder than ever,
trying to translate into English his Manual on Vertebroneurology and
preparing new books. He died unexpectedly of a heart attack after
nephrectomy.
We are witnesses to a rare phenomenon in medical science -- the
posthumous publication (all in Russia) of three major works in a
single year, including the Manual of Peripheral Nervous System
Diseases, demonstrating the dedication of Popelyanskiy’s followers.
His new book on eye-movements and gaze paralysis, which tackles
several controversial issues in classical neurology, was published at
the end of last year. Still, none of these works have been translated
into English. There were numerous reasons for the isolation of Soviet
science: many Russian scientists were prohibited from traveling to
international conferences and publishing abroad. At the same time, due
to a language barrier, foreign scientists had limited access to
Russian scientific literature.
One may be surprised how high quality research could be
performed in the economically underdeveloped Soviet Union. However,
disease-prevention, along with defense and space research, was well
funded, which is how Popelyanskiy could establish the National Center
of Vertebroneurology. The accomplishments of this remarkable scientist
deserve and need to be disseminated to the international community.
Yakov Popelyanskiy graduated from First Moscow Medical
Institute in 1940 and entered the professional field during World War
II, when he was chief physician of a Soviet Air Force regiment. He was
wounded during the war and, after the victory, continued his education
in Central Neurology Research Institute in Moscow, where he completed
his candidate dissertation. In that exploration, Yakov Popelyanskiy
examined the involvement of the third neuron of vestibular nerve,
described the oculogyric crisis, and was one of the first scientists
to discover the activating ascendant influence of the brain stem on
the cortex. A Noble Prize later acknowledged similar studies in the
West, but the Iron Curtain made the discovery of Yakov Popelyanskiy
totally unknown outside the Soviet Union.
Yakov always declined calls to become a member of the Communist Party,
which was a mandatory condition for professional advancement. Owing to
his political untrustworthiness and his Jewish heritage, which was a
particular blemish in the atmosphere of the “Conspiracy of Jewish
Doctors” in the last years of Stalin’s reign, Yakov was exiled first
close to the Siberian region, and then to a very poor (at that time)
Moldova Republic. Despite the isolation and continued harassment on
the part of “apparatchiks,” his talent was well known and he became a
sought-after professional. He was able to return to Moscow in 1955 to
resume his work in an inconspicuous outpatient clinic. The conditions
for scientific exploration there were inadequate, but his talent and
energy inspired those who worked with him, and that clinic became well
known for its success in treating patients with sciatica, back and
neck pain, as well as studies that related the genesis of those
diseases to “Intervertebral Osteochondrosis”. This term over years
became widely used in Eastern European countries, then spread to the
West, and has been accepted in the US almost 50 years later as a major
part of degenerative disc diseases specter.
The clinical evidence gathered during those years later formed the
basis of Yakov Popelyanskiy’s doctoral dissertation. However, further
expansion of his studies demanded a new venue. In 1957, he returned to
Siberia, this time on his own will, to join the Advanced Medical
Training Institute in the city of Novokuznetsk. While working there as
professor-in-chief of the neurological department, he created a new
direction in medicine. He put his research at the intersection of
neurology, orthopedics, neurosurgery, osteopathy and physical therapy.
Under his leadership, much research and multiple dissertations were
completed and this provincial Institute became famous throughout the
former Soviet Union. Overall, those were the happiest years of his
life.
In 1967, the already eminent professor was invited to join
Kazan State Medical Institute, where he managed the neurological
department and the Russian National Center of Vertebroneurology until
2000. A highly successful school of Vertebroneurology was formed
during those years, and a uniquely detailed manual on original
clinical discipline was written. Yakov Popelyanskiy brought European
ideas of manual therapy to Vertebroneurology, reciprocally upgraded
and partly united them. He considered that neurosurgeons and spinal
surgeons from one side, and osteopaths, chiropractors, physical and
manual therapists from another side, treat the same disease from
opposite ends but leave the main important neuropathological essence
unattended. By his estimation, less than 1% of patients needed the
help of neurosurgeons. Yakov Popelyanskiy was one of the first
neurologists, who in 1960-s brought attention to the fact, that pain
radiating from the spine to extremities very often has nothing to do
with nerve root compression, but may be referred pain from degenerated
disks, facet joints, ligaments, sympathetic nerves etc. In such cases
the spinal surgery directed to remove incidental herniated disc will
fail. He believed that the trained neurologist/vertebroneurologist has
to screen and select the patients for spinal surgery and thus to stop
the epidemic of diskectomies.
Popelyanskiy established the reflex and adaptive pathogenesis
of the cardinal vertebrogenic syndromes that explained the
interrelationship and feedback between spine, spinal cord and
myofascial structures. Describing and discovering the new entrapment
syndromes, he was one of the first to show that the majority of
vertebrogenic back and neck pains, muscular dystonic, dystrophic and
autonomic vascular manifestations are the result of the reflex
reaction to the irritation of the receptors of the afferent
sinuvertebral recurrent nerve. Yakov Popelyanskiy recognized that
vertebrogenic reflex muscular fixation (stabilization) is a major
counter-pathogenic (“sanogenic”) process that determines primary
relief and following re-compensation of the clinical crisis. The
timing of improvement is stipulated by the perfection of newly
developed locomotive patterns that alleviate muscular imbalance due to
abnormal discharge of intervertebral disks as well as connective,
articular, and cartilaginous structures of the afflicted vertebral
mobile segment. Yakov pointed out the ponderability of pathological
afferent internal and external stimuli, and proprioreception in the
forming of clinical picture of degenerative disk disease.
Yakov Popelyanskiy and his disciples studied multiple original
locomotive patterns including those relating to mechanical pathology
of neural and vascular pathways. The most known patterns include
scalenus syndrome with brachial plexus neuropathy and pyriformis
syndrome with sciatic neuropathy. Among the pathologies of the spinal
cord that Yakov Popelyanskiy discovered and explained was the
Vertebrogenic Ischemic Dorsal Column Syndrome.
Yakov’s interests and skills were not restricted by the neurology of
the spine. Every day he participated in clinical examinations of
patients with ailments of central and peripheral nervous system. He
was the editor of Russian translation of Travell and Simons’ classic
Myofacial Pain. Among more than 200 of his publications, there are
many books with topics of peripheral nervous system diseases, problems
of the eye, pathogenesis and clinical manifestation of botulism,
organization of medical work, and history of medicine. In his book on
anti-Semitism, he examined its paranoia from the standpoint of a
neurologist. Quite a few of his manuscripts have not yet been printed.
His personal achievements and those of his scientific school have now
been widely acknowledged in Russia and worldwide. There are several
Vertebroneurological Centers around the country. There exists the
World Vertebroneurological Association. Many conventions, conferences
and international congresses have been devoted to problems of
vertebroneurology. His disciples work around the world. Overall, Yakov
Popelyanskiy’s life work has contributed to a notable expansion of the
field of theoretical and practical neurology. His more than 40 year
research of Intervertebral Osteochondrosis as the main cause of the
back and neck pain, is being acknowledged in the U.S. now. It can only
be expected that soon his ideas will continue to gain support and be
further developed in our country. However, only a small portion of his
work has been translated into English. His most valuable life work,
the second edition of Manual of Vertebroneurology with the majority of
his original ideas, practical results, and achievements is currently
awaiting its English translator, editor, and publisher in the U.S.
There has been a fund established to create an opportunity for his
most essential work to come to life here in the United State
(“Orthopedic Neurology Research Fund “, 16716 68 Ave NE Suite #B1,
Kenmore WA, 98028 , call 425-486-8025, 206-407-7642).
A true man of science, Yakov Popelyanskiy was a genuine
teacher, completely dedicated to his students and his work. The
creativity of his thought was enhanced by an absolute scrupulousness
in his research and practical work. Despite his commitment to science,
he was a loving husband, caring father, and an adored grandfather, a
man of great respect and wisdom. His family, friends and colleagues
will forever feel the lack of the warmth of his soul, and the
generosity of his beautiful mind and spirit.
Yan Lupyan, MD, PhD,
D. Sc,
, Marina Sobol, MD, PhD, Igor Sobol, MD,
PhD, New Jersey, AAN Members;
Alex Popelyanskiy,
MD, PhD Russia, Gregory Korshin, PhD
|